|
The National Football League (NFL)
playoffs are a single-elimination tournament held at the end of the 16-game
regular season to determine the NFL champion. Six teams from each of the
league's two conferences qualify for the tournament based on regular season
records, and a tie-breaking procedure exists in the case of equal records. It
ends with the Super Bowl, the league's championship game.
NFL post-season history can be traced to the first NFL Championship Game in
1933, though in the early years, qualification for the game was based solely on
regular season records. The first true NFL playoff began in 1967, when four
teams qualified for the tournament. When the league merged with the American
Football League in 1970, the playoffs expanded to eight teams. The playoffs were
expanded to ten teams in 1978 and twelve teams in 1990.
Current playoff system

The 32-team league is divided into two conferences of 16
teams each: the American Football Conference (AFC) and the National Football
Conference (NFC). Since 2002, each conference has been further divided into 4
divisions of 4 teams each. The tournament brackets are made up of six teams from
each of the league's two conferences, following the end of the 16-game regular
season. Qualification into the playoffs are as follows:
The NFL Playoffs. Each of the 4 division winners is seeded 1–4 based on their
overall records. The two wild card teams (labeled Wild Card 1 and 2) are seeded
5th and 6th (with the better of the two having seed 5) regardless of their
records compared to the 4 division winners.
* The 4 division champions from each conference (the team in each division with
the best overall record), which are seeded 1 through 4 based on their overall
won-lost-tied record.
* Two wild card qualifiers (those non-division champions with the conference's
best winning percentages), which are seeded 5 and 6.
The first round of the playoffs is dubbed the Wild Card Playoffs (the league in
recent years has also used the term Wild Card Weekend). In this round, the
3rd-seeded division winner hosts the 6th seed wild card, and the 4th seed hosts
the 5th. The 1 and 2 seeds from each conference receive a bye in the first
round, which entitles these teams to automatic advancement to the second round,
the Divisional Playoffs, where they face the Wild Card Weekend survivors. Unlike
most tournaments, with a predetermined bracket, the second round of the playoffs
is "re-seeded"; the top seed always hosts the lowest surviving seed, while the
other two teams pair off.The two surviving teams from each conference's
Divisional Playoff games meet in the respective AFC and NFC Conference
Championship games, with the winners of those contests going on to face one
another in the Super Bowl.
If teams are tied (having the same regular season won-lost-tied record), the
playoff seeding is determined by a set of tie-breaking rules.
One potential disadvantage is that the two teams with the best records in a
conference could play each other before the conference championship if they're
in the same division (The better team would get the #1 seed, while the worse
team would only get the #5 seed as the top wild card team, and as shown in the
diagram, it is possible for the #1 division winner to play the top wild card
team in the divisional round) (See also the "Modification proposals" section
below).
Breaking ties
Often, teams will finish a season with identical records. It becomes necessary,
therefore, to devise means to break these ties, either to determine which teams
will qualify for the playoffs, or to determine seeding in the playoff
tournament. The rules below are applied in order until the tie is broken. If
three teams are tied for one playoff spot, the rules are applied only until the
first team qualifies. If multiple playoff spots are at stake, the rules are
applied in order until the first team qualifies, then the process is started
again for the remaining teams.
The tie-breaking rules have changed over the years, with the most changes being
made in 2002 to accommodate the league's realignment into eight four-team
divisions; record vs. common opponents and most of the other criteria involving
wins and losses were moved up higher in the tie-breaking list, while those
involving compiled stats such as points for and against were moved to the
bottom.
The current tiebreakers are as follows:
Divisional tiebreakers Wild Card tiebreakers
1. Head-to-head (best won-lost-tied percentage in games between the clubs).
2. Best won-lost-tied percentage in games played within the division.
3. Best won-lost-tied percentage in common games (games played against the same
opponents).
4. Best won-lost-tied percentage in games played within the conference.
5. Strength of victory (the combined won-lost-tied percentage of all the teams
that a club has defeated).
6. Strength of schedule (the combined won-lost-tied percentage of all the teams
that a club has played against).
7. Best combined ranking among conference teams in points scored and points
allowed.
8. Best combined ranking among all teams in points scored and points allowed.
9. Best net points in common games.
10. Best net points in all games.
11. Best net touchdowns in all games.
12. Coin toss
1. Head-to-head, if applicable.
2. Best won-lost-tied percentage in games played within the conference.
3. Best won-lost-tied percentage in common games, minimum of four.
4. Strength of victory.
5. Strength of schedule.
6. Best combined ranking among conference teams in points scored and points
allowed.
7. Best combined ranking among all teams in points scored and points allowed.
8. Best net points in conference games.
9. Best net points in all games.
10. Best net touchdowns in all games.
11. Coin toss.
A completely different, much simpler set of tie breaking rules are used to
determine the order in which teams pick in the NFL Draft. Overall record among
the 32 teams is ranked from lowest (#1) to highest (#30), with the Super Bowl
contenders getting #31 (loser) and #32 (winner). The following tiebreakers are
used:
1. Whether or not the team made the playoffs (if not, that team gets higher
draft spot).
2. Strength of schedule.
3. Coin toss.
Playoff and championship history
Further information: National Football League championships
For playoff games of the American Football League prior to the AFL-NFL merger,
see AFL playoffs.
The NFL's method for determining its champions has changed over the years.
Early years
From the league's founding in 1920 until 1932, there was no scheduled
championship game. From 1920–1923, the championship was awarded to a team by a
vote of team owners at the annual owners meeting. From 1924–1932, the team
having the best winning percentage was awarded the championship. As each team
played a different number of games, simply counting wins and losses would have
been insufficient. Additionally, tie games were not counted in the standings in
figuring winning percentage (under modern rules, ties count as ½ win and ½
loss).
The 1932 playoff game
In 1932, the Chicago Bears (6–1–6) and the Portsmouth Spartans (6–1–4) were tied
at the end of the season with the identical winning percentage of .857 (The
Green Bay Packers (10–3–1) had more wins, but a lower winning percentage (.769)
as calculated under the rules of the day, which omitted ties). An additional
game was therefore needed to determine a champion. It was agreed that the game
would be played in Chicago at Wrigley Field, but severe winter weather and fear
of a low turnout forced the game to be moved indoors to Chicago Stadium. The
game was played under modified rules on a shortened 80-yard dirt field, and the
Bears won with a final score of 9–0.As a result of the game, the Bears had the
better winning percentage (.875) and won the league title. The loss gave the
Spartans a final winning percentage of .750, and moved them to third place
behind the Packers. While there is no consensus that this game was a real
"championship" game (or even a playoff game), it generated considerable interest
and lead to the creation of the official NFL Championship Game in 1933.
Before the Super Bowl
Given the interest of the impromptu "championship game", and the desire of the
league to create a more equitable means of determining a champion, the league
divided into two conferences beginning in 1933. There was no tie-breaker system
in place, any ties in the final standings of either conference resulted in a
playoff game being played at the end of the regular season. Playoff games were
played in 1941, 1943, 1947, two games in 1950, one in 1952, 1957, 1958, and
1965. Since the venue and date of the championship game were often not known
until the last game of the season had been played, these playoff games sometimes
resulted in delaying the end of the season by one week.
For the 1967 NFL season, the NFL expanded to 16 teams, and split its two
conferences into two divisions each, with four teams in each division. The four
division champions would advance to the NFL playoffs, and to remain on schedule,
a tie-breaker system was introduced. The first round of playoffs determined the
conference's champion and its representative in the NFL Championship Game,
played the following week. Thus, 1967 was the first season there was a scheduled
playoff tournament to determine the teams to play for the NFL Championship.
During the three years (1967-69) that this playoff structure was in effect,
there was one use of the tie-breaker system. In 1967 the Los Angeles Rams and
Baltimore Colts ended the season tied at 11-1-2 for the lead in the Coastal
Division. The Colts came into the last game of the season undefeated, but were
beaten by the Rams. Though the Colts shared the best won/loss record in the NFL
that year, they failed to advance to the playoffs while three other teams with
worse records won their divisions. This event figured into the decision in 1970
to include a "wildcard" team in the playoff tournament.
During the 1960s, a third-place playoff game was played in Miami, called the
Playoff Bowl. It was contested in early January following the 1960–69 seasons.
Though offical playoff games at the time they were played, the NFL now
officially classifies these ten games (and statistics) as exhibitions, not as
playoff games.
AFL playoffs
Since it would eventually merge with the NFL, the history of the AFL's playoff
system merits some explanation. For the 1960–68 seasons, the AFL used the
two-divisional format identical to the NFL to determine its champion. There was
no tie-breaker system in place, so ties atop the Eastern Division final
standings in 1963 and Western Division in 1968 necessitated playoff games to
determine each division's representative in the championship.
For the 1969 season, a second round was added whereby the each division winner
played the second place team from the other division. The winners of this game
met in the AFL Championship Game.In the only year of this format, the AFL
Champion Kansas City Chiefs were actually the second place team in the Western
division. Thus they were the first non-division winner to win a Super Bowl (the
Chiefs would go on to decisively win Super Bowl IV that season).
The Super Bowl era
The Super Bowl began as an inter-league championship game between the AFL and
NFL. This compromise was the result of pressures the upstart AFL was placing on
the older NFL. The success of the rival league would eventually lead to a full
merger of the two leagues.
From the 1966 season to the 1969 season (Super Bowls I–IV) the game featured the
champions of the AFL and NFL. Since the 1970 season, the game has featured the
winners of the National Football Conference (NFC) and the American Football
Conference (AFC).
When the leagues merged in 1970, the new NFL (with 26 teams) reorganized into
two conferences of three divisions each. From the 1970 season to the 1977
season, four teams from each conference (for a total of eight teams) qualified
for the playoffs each year. These four teams included the three division
champions, and a fourth Wild Card team.
Originally, the home teams in the playoffs were decided based on a yearly
rotation.The league did not institute a seeding system for the playoffs until
1975, where the surviving clubs with the higher seeds were made the home teams
for each playoff round.Thus, the top seeded division winner played the wild card
team, and the remaining two division winners played at the home stadium of the
better seed. However, two teams from the same division could not meet prior to
the conference championship game.Thus, there would be times when the pairing in
the Divisional Playoff Round would be the 1 seed vs. the 3 seed and 2 vs. 4.
Following an expansion of the regular season from 14 to 16 games in the 1978
season, the league added one more wild card team for each conference. The two
wild card teams played the week before the division winners. The winner of this
game played the top seeded division winner as was done from 1970–1977. The
league continued to prohibit intra-divisional games in the Divisional Playoffs,
but allowed such contests in the Wild Card Round.This ten-team playoff format
was used through the 1989 season.Under this system, the Oakland Raiders became
the first Wild Card team to win a Super Bowl following the 1980 season.
During the strike-shortened 1982 season only nine regular season games were
played, and a modified playoff format was instituted. Divisional play was
ignored (there were some cases where division rivals had both games wiped out by
the strike), and the top eight teams from each conference (based on W-L-T
record) were advanced to the playoffs. This was the only year that teams with
losing records qualified for the playoffs, the 4-5 Cleveland Browns and the 4-5
Detroit Lions.
For the 1990 season, a third wild card team for each conference was added,
expanding the playoffs to twelve teams. The lowest-seeded division winner was
then "demoted" to the wild card week. Also, the restrictions on intra-divisional
games during the Divisional Playoffs were removed.This format continued until
the 2002 expansion and reorganization into eight divisions. In this current
format, as explained above, the 4 division winners and 2 wild cards are seeded
1–6, with the top 2 seeds receiving byes, and the highest seed in each round
guaranteed to play the lowest seed. Also, records do not always determine the
home field advantage, seeds always do. Thus it is possible that a division
champion could host a wild card playoff team that has a better win-loss record.
Modification proposals
Since the 2002 expansion to 8 divisions, there have been calls to expand the
playoffs to 14 teams. Proponents of expansion note the increased revenue that
could be gained from an additional two playoff games. They also note that the
12-team playoff system was implemented when the league only had 28 teams and six
divisions (of 4 to 5 teams each). With expansion to 32 teams aligned in eight
four-team divisions, there has been an effective loss of access to the playoff
structure for wild-card teams and greater access to teams in weak divisions (for
instance, in 2008, the San Diego Chargers and Arizona Cardinals clinched playoff
berths with only 8 wins each [though Arizona later earned a ninth by season's
end], but the New England Patriots, with 11 wins, failed to secure a wild card
spot). The opposition to such a move notes that an expansion of the playoffs
would "water down" the field by giving access to lower-caliber teams. Opponents
to expansion further point to the NBA Playoffs and the NHL Playoffs where 16
teams qualify for the post season, and there is often a decreased emphasis on
regular season performance as a result.
After the 2007 playoffs saw two wild card teams with better records
(Jacksonville Jaguars and eventual Super Bowl XLII champions New York Giants) go
on the road to defeat division winners (Pittsburgh Steelers and Tampa Bay
Buccaneers, respectively) during Wild Card Weekend, the NFL explored another
proposal to change the playoffs so that wild card teams with better regular
season records than division winners would host playoffs games. The NFL's
Competition Committee withdrew the request later that offseason[19], with
Atlanta Falcons president Rich McKay mentioning that they wanted the idea to
simply get a discussion going. New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft was a
strong opponent of the rule change, believing that "if you win a division, it's
good for your fans to know you will have a home game." |